Freshman Focus: Xavier Simpson

Dylan Burkhardt

Previously: Ibi Watson

A week before Xavier Simpson committed to Michigan, he had barely been mentioned as a Wolverine recruiting target. All of the attention had been on Detroit Jesuit point guard Cassius Winston and Simpson was already close to a decision and had just announced a list of four finalists that didn’t include Michigan.

Then after a couple of phone calls, Simpson stopped by Ann Arbor on the way back from an official visit to Wisconsin. The rest was history as Simpson pledged to John Beilein and his staff just days later.

Simpson went on to be named Mr. Basketball in the state of Ohio and he carried Lima Senior to the OHSAA State Championship game before falling one victory short of the ultimate goal. Along the way he put up some monster scoring games (59 points, 65 points) and big performances and cemented his place as a top-75 recruit.

If the story sounds familiar, it should. The parallels between Simpson’s recruitment and prep development and Trey Burke’s are eerie. Back when Michigan was pursuing Burke, he was the second point guard on its board and the thought was that the Wolverine staff would wait for Kevin Pangos to make a decision.

In the end, they offered Burke rather than wait for Pangos. Burke went on to win Mr. Basketball and took Northland to the state finals before dominating for two seasons at Michigan.

The comparisons in situation are so obvious that they are hard not to point out, but they also setup an unfair expectation for Simpson. He’s the highest rated member of Michigan’s incoming class and he should step immediately into the backup point guard role behind Derrick Walton, but it’s unfair to expect him to follow a similar career trajectory to Burke.

By the Numbers

  • Composite Rank: 4-star, 66th
  • Height: 6-foot
  • Weight: 180 lbs
  • EYBL Stats: 28.5 mpg, 15.9 ppg, 50.8 eFG%, 34.5 3p%, 4.4 rpg, 4.9 apg, 2.6 topg

Here’s a shot chart of Simpson’s play during the Nike EYBL circuit and five games at Lima Senior last season courtesy of Krossover.

Krossover Shot Chart - Xavier Simpson

Reasons for Excitement

  • Swagger: Most scouting reports of Simpson’s game focus on his leadership and will to win. There might not be as much flash to his game as some other guards, but words like toughness and motor seem to be found in just about any scouting report of Simpson’s game. On a Michigan team that lacked toughness at times last season, that sort of energy should be a welcome addition to the roster.
  • Transition Play: On film, Simpson stands out for his ability to get the ball and push the pace in transition. He attacks in the full court and can find his teammates as well as get all the way to the hoop. He shot an impressive 65% at the rim overall, but half of that production was in transition when he shot 70% at the rim.
  • Defense: Simpson might not be the biggest guard, but he will provide the perimeter quickness to shore up at least some of Michigan’s defensive woes. He might not be the best athlete at the point guard spot, but he’ll be a solid defender overall.

Big Questions

  • Half Court Offense: Watching Simpson’s EYBL film, a couple of trends start to stand out.  The first is that a majority of his offense at the EYBL level comes in transition. He’s in attack mode in the full court, but doesn’t always seem to create in the half court. The big question for any Michigan point guard is “can he play in the pick-and-roll game?” and right now there’s not enough evidence to judge that question either way.
  • Size: One reason that Simpson could struggle at times in the half court? He’s very small. His listed 6-foot, 180 pounds seems a bit generous and Derrick Walton has struggled at times throughout his career given his size at the one. His EYBL numbers are good around the rim, but he’ll have to prove that he can play at the high-major level despite his small frame.
  • Shooting: First things first, I think Simpson is a better shooter than conventional wisdom dictates. He hit 34% of his threes on the Nike EYBL circuit despite most scouting reports questioning his shooting ability. He also shot over 40% from the elbows and has a nice pull-up jumper. But to stand out offensively at his size, he needs to be able to knock down open shots.

Bottom Line

Simpson is going to play from day one in Ann Arbor. Last year Derrick Walton was forced to play 90.8% of available minutes in Big Ten play — the second most in the conference — as he was backed up by only Andrew Dakich. The point guard position isn’t an easy place to be a star as a freshman, but Simpson should be an immediate upgrade to Michigan’s backcourt depth.

For Walton, having a legitimate backup will be a terrific luxury. He won’t have to worry about pacing himself to try to play 38 or 39 minutes every night, avoiding foul trouble and running the team.

Simpson’s adjustment to the college level could shape how Michigan’s guard rotation shakes out. If he excels, it wouldn’t surprise me to see Beilein go with a two point guard look and allow Walton and Simpson to share the floor at times. The Walton, Abdur-Rahkman and Simpson trio could be all that Michigan needs to cover the 80 minutes available between the two guard spots. Walton’s catch-and-shoot and rebounding ability would enable a two-guard look like that to be successful, even if just for 5 to 10 minutes per game.

Simpson is the future of the point guard position at Michigan and, unlike the last three point guards in Ann Arbor, he’ll actually have a year to learn from a veteran.


“He understands the position,” Simpson’s father Quincey told “Playing the point guard is the quarterback of the team. You have to know every play. You have to know where everyone’s supposed to be at all times at both ends of the floor. He’s gotten better each year. We live by the marathon and not the sprint.

“They’re getting a hard-working player who finds ways to win, whether that’s scoring or being a pass-first point guard, a person who plays defense, a person who plays hard on both the offensive and defensive end, a person who just wants to win.”

  • Fab 5 Legends

    excited to see this kid, i think he will contribute even as a freshmen, he will get playing time regardless but i feel like Beilein can make him into a top PG in the nation in the next couple years…there are flashes of Trey Burke but those expectations are high, even if we get something similar ill be happy…im looking forward to Wagner development, he will be our XFactor in my opinion…Go Blue!

    • Champswest

      And he wears #3.

      • Fab 5 Legends

        exactly, the last guy to wear #3 was national player of the year and brought Michigan to the finals…

        i also like these Ohio kids that Beilein recruits; Burke & Levert being the most recent but i can see Watson & X being key players too

  • bobohle

    I don’t think the X man will disappoint us at all. I expect a bright career at Michigan for him.

  • Kenny

    i still want spike coming back for his 5th year

    • Ethan

      You do realize Spike is already playing for Purdue, right? Frankly, I appreciate what Spike did for us as a player, but I’m excited to actually have two guards that can play on the team at the same time. Spike hasn’t been healthy for two years.

  • Bigrange

    High motor, smaller size. Sounds a bit like Yogi Ferrell and he turned out ok for IU.