Big Ten’s Top 25 Players: 20-16

Dylan Burkhardt

With the official start of practice less than two months away, Inside the Hall and UM Hoops have again partnered to bring you a preseason breakdown of the top 25 players in the Big Ten for the 2015-2016 season.

Our selection process involved much deliberation to arrive at a list we hope will provide plenty of reaction and debate. The series will be broken into five parts and our second installment of players 20-16 is available below: (Previously: 25-21)

20. Rasheed Sulaimon, Maryland (6-foot-5, wing, senior)

19.3 mpg, 7.5 ppg, 2.0 rpg, 1.8 apg, 50.4 eFG percentage (20 games at Duke)

Expectations are sky high in College Park with Melo Trimble and Jake Layman returning to school and five-star big man Diamond Stone entering the mix. Duke transfer Rasheed Sulaimon should only add to the intrigue. Sulaimon arrived at Duke as a McDonald’s All-American and was named to the 2012-13 ACC All-Freshman team after averaging 11.3 points per game in his rookie year.

From there, his career never quite took off.  His production declined over three seasons in Durham – he averaged 7.5 points per game last year — and eventually he was dismissed in January. Now at Maryland, Sulaimon will hope a new environment sparks his career in his final season of eligibility. There are plenty of questions about how Sulaimon fits in College Park, but the one thing that can’t be questioned is his shooting ability. The 6-foot-5 guard shot 39% from long-distance over his career.

19. Jae’Sean Tate, Ohio State (6-foot-4, forward, sophomore)

22.0 mpg, 8.8 ppg, 5.0 rpg, 0.3 apg, 58.7 eFG percentage

Jae’Sean Tate started Ohio State’s final 16 games last season and it’s not hard to see why. Tate is a coach’s dream with his high motor, rebounding ability and all-around production. His game still might be a bit rough around the edges, but put Tate on the court and you know that he’s going to make plays.

In Big Ten action, Tate touted the conference’s best two-point shooting percentage (67.6%) and eighth-best offensive rebound percentage. For a 6-foot-4 freshman, those sort of numbers are almost unheard of. Tate is Ohio State’s lone returning starter from last year’s end-of-season lineup and it will be critical for Thad Matta’s team that he figures out a way to diversify his offensive game as a sophomore. He shot just 16% (3-of-19) behind the arc last season and handed out only 12 assists in 771 minutes.

18. Derrick Walton, Michigan (6-foot-1, point guard, junior)

33.3 mpg, 10.7 ppg, 4.7 rpg, 3.0 apg, 43.7 eFG percentage

Derrick Walton started at the point guard spot for Michigan’s 2013-14 Elite Eight team and was steady and consistent, hitting a number of big shots in big games to help that group win the Big Ten by a wide margin. His stellar freshman season earned him a top-15 spot on last year’s preseason list, but a turf-toe injury sustained in the fifth game of last season sent his sophomore season careening off track. Walton played through the injury until late January — hitting a regulation buzzer-beater to send Michigan into overtime against Wisconsin — before shutting it down for the rest of the season.

Walton’s numbers were down across the board as a sophomore, but he was clearly plagued by the injury. He shot just 32.4% on two-point attempts for the season and a meager 17.1% on twos in Big Ten games. Despite the injury, he was still one of best rebounding guards in the Big Ten, cracking the conference’s top 20 in defensive rebounding rate despite standing just 6-foot tall. Expect Walton to bounce back from those injury-affected numbers and get back on track as a junior.

17. Malcolm Hill, Illinois (6-foot-6, wing, junior)

30.6 mpg, 14.4 ppg, 4.8 rpg, 1.3 apg, 50.3 eFG percentage

Malcolm Hill is one the most efficient scorers in the Big Ten. The 6-foot-6 wing was ranked as the sixth best shooter in the Big Ten, and second among returning players, according to Shot Analytics’ points above expectation metric which compares points scored on field goal attempts to expected points based on shot location. Hill scored the ball at all three levels — at the rim (65%), mid-range (50%) and three-point range (39%) — while still getting to the free throw line and keeping his turnover numbers down.

Despite his scoring prowess, we’d still like to see Hill diversify his game. His assist rate was below-average for a wing player and his rebounding numbers leave a bit to be desired. With Tracy Abrams out for another season, this is a great opportunity for Hill to expand his game and start to fill that void.

16. Bryant McIntosh, Northwestern (6-foot-3, guard, sophomore)

33.3 mpg, 11.4 ppg, 4.7 apg, 2.5 rpg, 48.4 eFG percentage

Lightly recruited by high major programs until later in his high school career, McIntosh had dreams of playing in the Big Ten and found a good fit in Evanston. The conference had a loaded freshman class last season with D’Angelo Russell, Melo Trimble, James Blackmon Jr. and Jae’Sean Tate. The Greensburg (Ind.) native joined that group on the league’s all-freshman team. He owned the league’s second best assist rate at 32.6 percent and hit better than 36 percent on 3s in his first season. More importantly, the rebuilding Northwestern program had the luxury of inserting him right into the starting lineup from day one. That experience should pay major dividends as he enters year two at the reigns of a Northwestern team that should find its way out of the bottom four of the Big Ten standings for the first time since 2012.

  • three_goggles

    15. Jake Layman
    14. Zak Irvin
    13. James Blackmon Jr.
    12. Bronson Koenig
    11. Jarrod Uthoff
    10. Eron Harris
    9. Caleb Swanigan
    8. AJ Hammons
    7. Shavon Shields
    6. Diamond Stone
    5. Denzel Valentine
    4. Caris Levert
    3. Nigel Hayes
    2. Yogi Ferrell
    1. Melo Trimble

    (Also in doing this, I realized Troy Williams and Deyonta Davis didn’t make my I’m very interested to see what 2 of these 17 aren’t even in the top 25)

    • A2MIKE

      I think Troy Williams makes the cut, but Davis does not.

      1. Melo Trimble
      2. Yogi Ferrell
      3. Nigel Hayes
      4. AJ Hammons
      5. Diamond Stone
      6. Denzel Valentine
      7. Caris LeVert
      8. Caleb Swanigan
      9. Eron Harris
      10. Blackmon Jr.
      11. Uthoff
      12. Layman
      13. Williams
      14. Irvin
      15. Koenig

      I don’t think Shields will be on this list.

      • Kyle Nickander

        I scrolled back up to the top of the page to make sure I had the proper title for listing these 25 players. Wanted to make sure it was top players of Big Ten, & not worded some way that you/me/anyone might think it was “Top players for each team?” I over think many things!! Also, I am from Indiana, but I’m a huge Purdue Boilermaker fan so I have been eating caca my entire life(unless you count the 2 years Big Dog Robinson brought his talent to West Lafayette but still came up short against Duke in the 16, or 8?).
        Point of all my rambling: You don’t feel Davis makes the top 25 cut. Not aware of who you support, or if you are a D1 BB fan all around? Davis, was/is an unflattering player. Not sure that is the proper word. Anyway, football, basketball, even baseball & soccer make their major highlights on Sports Center by someone doing a 360 dunk, a QB throwing a Hail Mary to win a game, walk-off HR’s in the bottom of the 16th, or Lionel Messi dribbling 3/4 of the field, in & out & around defenders ’til he finally makes a shot at the goal in an area 28 & a half inch wide!! All offenses plays. In fact, changing subjects a bit, they say the lack of offense is one reason soccer hasn’t done very well in the US(personally, all the non-soccer/futbol fans in the US can have their other sports. The World Cup & just qualifying to get there is awesome. I love soccer as much as I do BB, BB, Hockey, Tennis, Golf, but… maybe not football). Again, my point, I can understand you not thinking Davis is one of the Top 25. I understand, but we’ll have to agree to disagree because I think he should be on there. The value to his team last year spoke volumes in his talent as an all-around great ball player. Granted, I bet he does not work on his offensive game as much when Matt Painter tells him, “Hey, you’re taking D’Angelo Russell on Saturday so make sure your feet are feeling as lite & quick as ever! You gotta’ be there for his quick-fire 3’s, & when he fakes one & goes to the hole! We can’t have A.J. in early foul trouble so it’s all on you!”
        Last thing: You’re also replacing him, or saying Williams(A Hoosier=AAAAHhhh!!!) makes it & Davis doesn’t. And as I read it again, am I completely off base? Are we speaking of the same Davis? WOW! My apologies if you are speaking about Deyonta? I am sorry, but I’m also in it for all enjoyment. I hold no grudges or even dislike IU that much anymore. I just like good D1 BB, when they aren’t making $ yet. Well, lots of $$ yet.

        • I believe he’s talking about Deyonta Davis.

          • A2MIKE


  • bobohle

    I would say by seasons end Walton will be above McCintosh and Hill if not higher yet.

  • Mattski

    Wow. Judging by who makes the last ten, the Big Ten looks to be loaded with great players!

  • Corperryale

    Sucks that only the so-called Big Three will be on this list for Michigan. I’d put Aubrey Dawkins ahead of some of the random Wisconsin, Illinois, and NW guys I’ve seen so far.

    Random observations:

    I think Jae’sean Tate probably belongs higher.

    Having seen Denzel Valentine at the Pan Am games, I can (grudgingly) see him as a serious POY candidate.

    I also think Koenig will be exposed on a Dekkerless and Kaminskyless Wisconsin squad. No doubt he will hugely overrated on this list.

    An interesting wild card will be Costello. A very punchable guy but also a handful every time we play them. I would leave him off out of spite.